Nonlinear independent component analysis (ICA) provides an appealing framework for unsupervised feature learning, but the models proposed so far are not identifiable. Here, we first propose a new intuitive principle of unsupervised deep learning from time series which uses the nonstationary structure of the data. Our learning principle, time-contrastive learning (TCL), finds a representation which allows optimal discrimination of time segments (windows). Surprisingly, we show how TCL can be related to a nonlinear ICA model, when ICA is redefined to include temporal nonstationarities. In particular, we show that TCL combined with linear ICA estimates the nonlinear ICA model up to point-wise transformations of the sources, and this solution is unique --- thus providing the first identifiability result for nonlinear ICA which is rigorous, constructive, as well as very general.

There has been a lot of progress taking the successes of supervised techniques and extending them to unsupervised domains by defining an interesting label to predict, and this paper continues this trend by highlighting the task of discriminating between time windows. Furthermore, I think the emphasis on the importance of identifiability for nonlinear ICA and showing how it is solved in this case is a timely contribution. However, these contributions were somewhat muted by other shortcomings of the approach which make me doubt the robustness and generality of the method. This is a significant source of prior knowledge to include in the experiments and makes the comparisons unfair. In particular the comment that "none of the hidden units seem to represent artefacts, in contrast to ICA" rings a bit hollow since it seems that the elimination of artifacts was really achieved through hand-picked choice in the model.

Intrator (1990) proposed a feature extraction method that is related to recent statistical theory (Huber, 1985; Friedman, 1987), and is based on a biologically motivated model of neuronal plasticity (Bienenstock et al., 1982). This method has been recently applied to feature extraction in the context of recognizing 3D objects from single 2D views (Intrator and Gold, 1991). Here we describe experiments designed to analyze the nature of the extracted features, and their relevance to the theory and psychophysics of object recognition.

We address the problem of building theoretical models that help elucidate the function of the visual brain at computational/algorithmic and structural/mechanistic levels. We seek to understand how the receptive fields and topographic maps found in visual cortical areas relate to underlying computational desiderata. We view the development of sensory systems from the popular perspective of probability density estimation; this is motivated by the notion that an effective internal representational scheme is likely to reflect the statistical structure of the environment in which an organism lives. We apply biologically based constraints on elements of the model. The thesis begins by surveying the relevant literature from the fields of neurobiology, theoretical neuroscience, and machine learning. After this review we present our main theoretical and algorithmic developments: we propose a class of probabilistic models, which we refer to as "energy-based models", and show equivalences between this framework and various other types of probabilistic model such as Markov random fields and factor graphs; we also develop and discuss approximate algorithms for performing maximum likelihood learning and inference in our energy based models. The rest of the thesis is then concerned with exploring specific instantiations of such models. By performing constrained optimisation of model parameters to maximise the likelihood of appropriate, naturalistic datasets we are able to qualitatively reproduce many of the receptive field and map properties found in vivo, whilst simultaneously learning about statistical regularities in the data.

Nonlinear independent component analysis (ICA) provides an appealing framework for unsupervised feature learning, but the models proposed so far are not identifiable. Here, we first propose a new intuitive principle of unsupervised deep learning from time series which uses the nonstationary structure of the data. Our learning principle, time-contrastive learning (TCL), finds a representation which allows optimal discrimination of time segments (windows). Surprisingly, we show how TCL can be related to a nonlinear ICA model, when ICA is redefined to include temporal nonstationarities. In particular, we show that TCL combined with linear ICA estimates the nonlinear ICA model up to point-wise transformations of the sources, and this solution is unique --- thus providing the first identifiability result for nonlinear ICA which is rigorous, constructive, as well as very general.

Intrator (1990) proposed a feature extraction method that is related to recent statistical theory (Huber, 1985; Friedman, 1987), and is based on a biologically motivated model of neuronal plasticity (Bienenstock et al., 1982). This method has been recently applied to feature extraction in the context of recognizing 3D objects from single 2D views (Intrator and Gold, 1991). Here we describe experiments designed to analyze the nature of the extracted features, and their relevance to the theory and psychophysics of object recognition. 1 Introduction Results of recent computational studies of visual recognition (e.g., Poggio and Edelman, 1990) indicate that the problem of recognition of 3D objects can be effectively reformulated in terms of standard pattern classification theory. According to this approach, an object is represented by a few of its 2D views, encoded as clusters in multidimentional space. Recognition of a novel view is then carried out by interpo-460 3D Object Recognition Using Unsupervised Feature Extraction 461 lating among the stored views in the representation space.

Intrator (1990) proposed a feature extraction method that is related to recent statistical theory (Huber, 1985; Friedman, 1987), and is based on a biologically motivated model of neuronal plasticity (Bienenstock et al., 1982). This method has been recently applied to feature extraction in the context of recognizing 3D objects from single 2D views (Intrator and Gold, 1991). Here we describe experiments designed to analyze the nature of the extracted features, and their relevance to the theory and psychophysics of object recognition. 1 Introduction Results of recent computational studies of visual recognition (e.g., Poggio and Edelman, 1990) indicate that the problem of recognition of 3D objects can be effectively reformulated in terms of standard pattern classification theory. According to this approach, an object is represented by a few of its 2D views, encoded as clusters in multidimentional space. Recognition of a novel view is then carried out by interpo-460 3D Object Recognition Using Unsupervised Feature Extraction 461 lating among the stored views in the representation space.

Gold Center for Neural Science, Brown University Providence, RI 02912, USA Shimon Edelman Dept. of Applied Mathematics and Computer Science, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot 76100, Israel Abstract Intrator (1990) proposed a feature extraction method that is related to recent statistical theory (Huber, 1985; Friedman, 1987), and is based on a biologically motivated model of neuronal plasticity (Bienenstock et al., 1982). This method has been recently applied to feature extraction in the context of recognizing 3D objects from single 2D views (Intrator and Gold, 1991). Here we describe experiments designed to analyze the nature of the extracted features, and their relevance to the theory and psychophysics of object recognition. 1 Introduction Results of recent computational studies of visual recognition (e.g., Poggio and Edelman, 1990)indicate that the problem of recognition of 3D objects can be effectively reformulated in terms of standard pattern classification theory. According to this approach, an object is represented by a few of its 2D views, encoded as clusters in multidimentional space. Recognition of a novel view is then carried out by interpo-460 3D Object Recognition Using Unsupervised Feature Extraction 461 lating among the stored views in the representation space.